World News : A case from Singapore has sparked a wide debate online about compassion for animals versus strict public laws. A 71-year-old woman has been fined S$3,200 (around ₹2.27 lakh) for repeatedly feeding wild birds—mainly pigeons—despite prior warnings and penalties.
The woman, identified as Sanmugamathan Shamala, was penalised under the country’s Wildlife Act. Court records show she pleaded guilty to four charges, while five additional similar incidents were also taken into consideration during sentencing.
Not the first offence
This was not her first violation. In May 2025, Shamala had already been fined S$1,200 for the same offence and had given a written undertaking to the court that she would not repeat the act. However, authorities said she resumed feeding birds within a month.
Video evidence presented
Prosecutors submitted video footage and supporting evidence showing that between July 2025 and January 2026, Shamala fed pigeons at least nine times near her Toa Payoh flat, using grains and bread.
Why feeding birds is banned
Authorities argued that feeding wild birds:
-
Leads to public hygiene issues,
-
Disrupts ecological balance, and
-
Causes uncontrolled growth of bird populations.
Singapore enforces strict rules to maintain cleanliness and environmental order, and repeated violations attract heavier penalties.
Political outreach, but behaviour continued
The court was informed that the woman had even met her local Member of Parliament, expressing regret over her actions. However, she was reportedly caught feeding birds again just three days after the meeting.
Social media divided
The case has divided public opinion online.
-
Some users say imposing such a heavy fine on an elderly woman is harsh.
-
Others argue that repeated disregard for the law, even after warnings and penalties, leaves authorities with no option but to act firmly.
The case has reignited discussions on animal welfare, civic responsibility, and strict urban laws in highly regulated cities like Singapore.
